
The décor at The Ruffed Grouse Tavern is pleasingly layered, a dining room that seems to have gathered its treasures over generations rather than in a single design commission.

That’s by intent. For hotelier Jason Reeves, owner of Highlander Mountain House and The Outpost Inn, the goal has always been for his properties to feel “completely contextual,” rooted in the Plateau and Appalachia. Highlander, an 1880s building reimagined as an English country house, tells three intertwined stories: the Scots-Irish settlers, the Cherokee people who preceded them, and the artists of Black Mountain College. William Morris wallpaper, Cherokee arrowheads, Josef Albers prints, Victorian taxidermy, and furnishings of assorted vintages create an atmosphere that is warm, wonderfully eccentric, and never stuffy – an appealing place to settle in for dinner.

The kitchen belongs to Chef Jason Voiselle, who arrived at the start of the summer season, and his cooking is just as rooted in place. When I visited in early October, his fall menu was only three weeks old and almost entirely new. Chef Jason grew up in a restaurant family in Sarasota, graduated at the top of his class from the culinary program at A-B Tech in Asheville, and spent much of his career in the private clubs of Naples, Florida.
His cooking starts from Southern tradition and borrows freely from global spice blends. He favors complex blends over a single herb, he says, because they add “a little mystery. Like, oh, what is that I’m getting?” He is equally pragmatic about sourcing. His longtime supplier, Sweet Grass Dairy of Thomasville, Georgia, is “not next door,” he says, “but they’re still local.” And he is candid about the limits of a small kitchen: “We choose our battles.”

There are comforting staples that speak to the tavern part of the restaurant’s name, such as the enormous Brasstown Beef short rib, stacked high over corn-and-jalapeño spoonbread with chow-chow and crispy okra spears that may be the world’s best. General Manager and Beverage Director Jeremy Carter admits the staff “had to beg” to keep it on the menu. It’s the kind of food Chef Jason describes as “a basic food, but excellent,” as is his rendition of Carolina shrimp and grits: Anson Mills heritage grits enriched with Sweet Grass Dairy Georgia Gouda, braised collard greens, Benton’s country ham, roasted heirloom tomatoes, and potlikker sauce.

Chef Jason Voiselle
But something more sophisticated is happening in the kitchen too. You can see it in an extraordinary Florida red snapper, a weekly seafood feature on my visit. Exquisitely fresh, delicate, and perfectly cooked, it sat over Israeli couscous in a shimmering pumpkin-sage brodo with braised fennel, romanesco, and micro leeks. The broth carried just the right amount of autumn sweetness.
My photographer swore she didn’t eat fish, but after one bite she was converted. When Chef Jason stopped by our table, I told him seafood might be his superpower. “My roots are in Florida,” he replied.

That combination of polish and play runs through the meal. A cast-iron skillet of Parker House rolls arrives beneath a seedy, everything-bagel-style crust, with garlic-herb butter and Maldon salt. The blue crab and apple Johnny cake turns a Southern staple into what Chef Jason calls “a souped-up pancake”: a warm cornmeal cake topped with jumbo lump crab and a Honeycrisp apple-and-celery salad, finished with cider-mustard crème and chive oil.

The roasted heirloom carrots, coated in Middle Eastern dukkah, sit on whipped feta with bourbon-smoked benne seeds, house-preserved lemon, and mint, drizzled with local honey infused with Calabrian chilies. Chef Jason admitted that he introduced them primarily as a vegetarian option and was surprised by their popularity. I wasn’t.
And is there a salad more irresistible than one featuring burrata? Here, creamy local burrata meets poached spiced pears, toasted pumpkin seeds, pickled red onion, and baby kale in a maple-sherry vinaigrette. The fall panzanella brings together delicata squash, roasted grapes, shaved fennel, spiced walnuts, Georgia Gouda, and toasted focaccia in a cider-Dijon vinaigrette.

You may have surmised by now that Chef Jason is not afraid of flavor. Consider the house-made sweet potato gnocchi: bright orange, pillowy puffs in pepita pesto cream with roasted cauliflower, porter-infused Sweet Grass Dairy tomme, and pickled chilies. They seemed to melt on my tongue. Pecan-crusted Sunburst Farms trout, a mountain classic, sits on Parmesan-and-pumpkin risotto with bacon-braised leeks, crispy sage, and cranberry brown-butter beurre blanc, crowned with smoked trout roe.
“Decadent” was the word at our table, and it fit. The herb-grilled rack of lamb comes with roasted kabocha pumpkin, charred broccolini, and a butternut squash and white cheddar spoonbread so good it deserves its own fan club. The battles he has chosen are clearly the right ones.

Jeremy’s wine pairings were savvy from start to finish. A sparkling pét-nat Chenin Blanc opened the meal, followed by a crisp Greek Assyrtiko. With the trout and short rib, he poured Château Léoube’s 2025 Love by Léoube Rosé, fresh with strawberry and red-fruit notes. For the lamb, notoriously difficult to pair, he chose a lightly chilled Loire Valley Cabernet Franc made by carbonic maceration, its bright fruit balanced by enough tannin to stand up to the meat.
The most interesting pour came last. With pumpkin spice cheesecake, Jeremy served Eda Rhyne Appalachian Fernet, an intensely herbal, bittersweet digestif distilled in Asheville from more than 40 wild-foraged botanicals and spices. Floral and bracing, with less mint than its Italian cousin Fernet-Branca, it made a distinctly Appalachian finale.

The menu will change again in December, with new features every week in the meantime. Starters range from $13 to $38 and mains from $28 to $68. Locals will have every reason to return, and visitors will find a dining room, and a kitchen, that could only be here.
Reservations may be made at resy.com or highlandermountainhouse.com/tavern.
Favorites Count: 0
